|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 155-161
Iranian nurses' perceptions of the conditions of the families with terminally ill patients: Family in limbo
Reza Norouzadeh, Monireh Anoosheh, Fazlollah Ahmadi
Department of Nursing, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
|Date of Web Publication||1-Aug-2019|
Department of Nursing, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Understanding the conditions of terminally-ill patients' family members is the first step in reducing their emotional distress. Objectives: The aim of this study was to explore nurses' perceptions of the conditions of terminally ill patients' families. Methods: This qualitative content analysis study was conducted in 2016–2017. Participants were 24 nurses purposively recruited from 14 hospitals in Tehran, Iran. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and analyzed through conventional content analysis. Results: Participants' perceptions were categorized into two main categories, namely, behavioral and emotional turmoil and perceived worries. The two subcategories of the first category were family turmoil after receiving bad news and family members' violent behaviors after receiving bad news. The second category included four subcategories, namely, feeling guilty, worries about patient's fate, worries about the aggravation of patient's conditions, and financial worries. The main theme of the study was family in limbo. Conclusion: Terminally ill patients' family members are in limbo due to behavioral and emotional turmoil and different worries. Nurses can use the findings of this study to help terminally ill patients' family members undergo a healthy grief.
Keywords: End-of-life care, Family, Nurse, Qualitative research
|How to cite this article:|
Norouzadeh R, Anoosheh M, Ahmadi F. Iranian nurses' perceptions of the conditions of the families with terminally ill patients: Family in limbo. Nurs Midwifery Stud 2019;8:155-61
|How to cite this URL:|
Norouzadeh R, Anoosheh M, Ahmadi F. Iranian nurses' perceptions of the conditions of the families with terminally ill patients: Family in limbo. Nurs Midwifery Stud [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 Aug 21];8:155-61. Available from: http://www.nmsjournal.com/text.asp?2019/8/3/155/263871
| Introduction|| |
Nurses often encounter families who suffer from the imminent loss of one of their members. These families need to deal with a wide variety of duties and experience different negative psychological problems in the process of caregiving to their terminally ill patients.,, Such a condition makes families emotionally fragile. Thus, nurses need to provide them with quality cultural and ethical care in order to restore their emotional well-being. This type of care can be provided in light of artistic interaction with families and proper understanding of their conditions.
Assessment of families to understand their conditions in the terminal life stages of their ill members is a prerequisite to provide them with quality care. Such assessment and understanding enable nurses to identify families' needs and conditions, reduce families' emotional strains, and improve care quality, families' mental health, and families' decision-making ability. On the contrary, nurses' inadequate understanding of families' emotional conditions can cause families' varying levels of stress, anxiety, and helplessness.
Previous studies on terminally ill patients' families mainly focused on their physical and emotional suffering, and their psychological problems before and after the death of their patients.,, Similarly, studies in Iran dealt mainly with the experiences of the family members of the patients with vegetative status and the psychological needs of the family caregivers of dying cancer patients. Hence, there is a wide knowledge gap regarding nurses' perceptions of the conditions of families with terminally ill patients. On the other hand, given the patient-centered approach to care delivery in most health-care centers in Iran, the main concern of the nurses who provide end-of-life care seems to be patient management and hence terminally ill patients' family members and their needs are usually taken for granted. The present study was conducted to fill these gaps.
The aim of this study was to explore nurses' perceptions of the conditions of families with terminally ill patients.
| Methods|| |
Research design, participants, and setting
This study was conducted using an inductive qualitative content analysis. This design was chosen due to the paucity of information about the study subject matter. Participants were selected through purposive sampling with maximum variation in order to ensure the inclusion of different viewpoints in the study. Selection criteria were a clinical work experience of at least 2 years in dealing with the families of terminally ill patients. Accordingly, 14 male and 10 female nurses were selected from different hospital wards, namely, oncology care wards (n = 5), emergency departments (n = 4), intensive care units (ICUs) (n = 7), coronary care units (n = 3), neonatal ICUs (n = 1), medical units (n = 3), and transplantation units (n = 1). Participants held bachelor's (n = 15), master's (n = 7), or Doctor of Philosophy (n = 2) degrees and were working as staff nurses, head nurses, or charge nurses. The study setting consisted of 14 hospitals in Tehran, Iran, with wards and units for providing care to terminally ill patients.
Data were collected from March 2016 to February 2017 through face-to-face in-depth semi-structured interviews. All interviews were conducted in Persian by the first author in a quiet room in participants' preferred places. Each interview began using a broad question, “May you please tell me about your experiences of the emotions and the feelings of families with terminally ill patients?” Subsequently, other broad and probing questions were asked to collect more in-depth data. These questions included “What do you mean by this?” “Could you explain more about this?” and “How did you understand that the family felt guilty after receiving bad news about their patient's conditions.” Interviews lasted 30 min, on average. All interviews were audiotaped and transcribed verbatim. Sampling and data collection were continued up to data saturation.
This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran (approval code: 52D.9109). Participants were informed about the study aim and the voluntary participation in the study, and then, personal informed consent was obtained verbally from each of them. We also attempted to collect genuine data and protect participants' identity through allocating a numerical code to each interview. Moreover, the confidentiality of the data was guaranteed through not discussing interview content with others.
Data analysis and trustworthiness
Data analysis was carried out manually and simultaneously with data collection using Graneheim and Lundman's conventional content analysis. After reading each interview transcript for several times and grasping its main ideas, the words, sentences, and paragraphs which were relevant to the study aim were extracted as meaning units. Then, these meaning units were abstracted and labeled as codes. The generated codes were categorized according to their similarities and differences into subcategories and categories. Finally, the main theme of the study was extracted to describe the latent content of the data [Table 1].
|Table 1: Nurses' perceptions of the conditions of terminally ill patients' family members|
Click here to view
Trustworthiness was applied to the study using the criteria proposed by Lincoln and Guba. Credibility was established through prolonged engagement with the data and member checking. In member checking, several interview transcripts together with their related primary codes were provided to participants to check if our generated codes accurately reflected their experiences. Moreover, dependability was applied through peer checking, during which coauthors reviewed and confirmed the accuracy of data analysis. To ensure confirmability, all steps of the study were clearly described for the purpose of external auditing. Finally, transferability was ensured through maximum variation sampling respecting participants' gender, educational levels, and work experience.
| Results|| |
Nurses' perceptions of the conditions of terminally ill patients' family members were conceptualized as “family in limbo.” As presented in [Table 1], this main theme included the two main categories of behavioral and emotional turmoil and perceived worries.
According to the participants, the families of terminally ill patients are in a state of great confusion and emotional disturbance and experience intense emotions, which affect their physical and behavioral status. Behavioral and emotional turmoil reflects families' mental involvement after receiving bad news about their patients' critical conditions. Participants highlighted that terminally ill patients' families experience emotional and behavioral disturbances after receiving bad news such as brain death, patient's vegetative status, patient preparation for organ donation, likelihood of death, unsuccessful cardiopulmonary resuscitation, and patient death. Our participants noted that in their settings, terminally ill patients' families had sometimes been informed about their patients' conditions by expressions, such as “The disease may recur,” “Everything is useless for your patient,” “Don't expect miracles for your patient,” “There is no higher chance of recovery by taking the patient to other centers,” “Patient's life depends on medications and equipment,” and “The patient may die despite medications.” Participants' perceptions of the behavioral and emotional turmoil of terminally ill patients' family members were categorized into two subcategories, namely family turmoil after receiving bad news and family members' violent behaviors after receiving bad news.
Family turmoil after receiving bad news
After receiving bad news about their patients' terminal conditions, family members experience emotional problems such as agitation, fear, desperation, depression, and crying. Remembering an emergency situation, an emergency-room nurse said: “It was an emergency situation and patient's family members were agitated. When they saw their patient was on the bed with critical conditions, they became more agitated. Thus, they did not understand what I was saying to them and just wanted to get rid of that situation. It was very annoying to the family” (P 2). An intensive care nurse also described a mother whose son had been diagnosed with cancer: “When the mother saw that her son was in bad conditions, she became overwhelmed, distressed, and quite pale. She really didn't know what to do. She just cried. Her conditions were so disturbing that I really couldn't control myself and hugged her and started crying. She also tightly grasped my hands and cried. I really couldn't understand her feelings” (P 19).
Family members' violent behaviors after receiving bad news
Nurses frequently commented that, after receiving bad news about their patients' terminal conditions, some family members may show violent behaviors such as damaging equipment, verbal threat, insult to nurses, and quarrel with them. A pediatric oncology nurse said: “She suddenly lost her control. After she returned to her normal conditions, she found that she had broken ICU windows. She apologized. But, when she heard her child was dying in ICU, she completely lost her control” (P 10). An emergency-room nurse also commented in this regard: “He came inside and shouted loudly, “You want to kill my brother.” He threatened to kill us. We asked him to wait. Then, we got into a fight. I attempted to prevent him from taking any physical action, but he insulted me and started talking trash. He used a lot of foul language and even used the “f” word. He just wanted to hit me” (P 21).
Besides understanding emotional disturbances of terminally ill patients' families, our participants reported a set of annoying emotions which indicated worries in families. The four subcategories of this category were feeling guilty, worries about patient's fate, worries about the aggravation of patient's conditions, and financial worries.
Participants noted that in the last days of terminally ill patients' lives, their families show reactions that are indicative of their feeling of guilt. These reactions include going through fire and water to save their patients' lives, asking nurses to administer less painful treatments, and even requesting the discontinuation of life-saving therapies in order to alleviate patients' suffering. Such feeling of guilt is due to factors such as neglectful behaviors toward patients in the past or witnessing their suffering as a result of treatments. An oncology nurse said: “At that moment, family members were in a situation that they wanted to do whatever they could for their patient. Two days later, they saw that their patient was under ventilator. However, they didn't feel any improvement in patient's conditions. Thus, they felt guilty over consenting to such painful treatments for their patient and asked me to disconnect the patient from the ventilator and remove tubes from the patient's body. They even threatened that they would remove tubes themselves if I refrained. Such behaviors were due to their emotional distress” (P 11).
Worries about patient's fate
Worries over patient's indefinite future, lack of control over patient's conditions, recurrence of patient's problems, and occurrence of unexpected events can cause distress, anxiety, and confusion for family members. A nurse in the transplantation unit said: “Family members repeatedly ask me about the future of their patient. They ask me if it is ok to take their patient to another doctor” (P 12).
According to participants, family members' worries over their patients' indefinite future make them feel intense emotions, reduce their rational thinking ability, and cause them decisional uncertainties. A coronary care nurse said: “Family members were in a real perplexity. They didn't know whether let their mother die or donate half of her life to another patient., they were between denial and acceptance and couldn't make their final decision” (P 24).
Worries about the aggravation of patient's conditions
Our participants noted that while family members expect improvements in their patients' conditions, sudden deterioration of patients' conditions causes worries for them. Most family members continuously strive to save their patients at any cost. They seek information about their patients' conditions, treatments, and prognoses through the families of the patients with similar conditions or from the Internet. However, information seeking is associated with greater worries about patient's conditions and greater uncertainties about the final decision. A pediatric oncology nurse said: “A mother insisted that she liked another doctor to visit her daughter because she wanted to save her. I talked to her a lot; but it was futile. Thus, I talked to the head of our department to change the patient's doctor. Subsequently, the chemotherapy protocol was changed. Two weeks later, the mother told that she wanted the first doctor. She justified her new decision by saying that the new chemotherapy regimen had caused her daughter greater suffering and pain” (P 9).
According to our participants, the family members of terminally ill patients have many financial worries because of factors such as their inadequate income, incomplete insurance coverage, additional costs associated with patient visits by others, and employment loss due to the need for permanent presence in medical centers. On the other hand, they may have worries over damages to their families' dignity and honor due to financial assistance provided to them by health-care centers or charities. Patients' long stay in hospital also causes financial worries for some families and may eventually require them to decide on treatment discontinuation. An intensive care nurse commented: “We had a patient in ICU whose family did not have a good financial status. The family was no longer able to afford their patient's treatments and ICU stay. Thus, family members asked us to disconnect their patient from ventilator and discontinue treatments” (P 1).
| Discussion|| |
Nurses' perceptions of the conditions of terminally ill patients' family members were conceptualized as family in limbo. In Persian literature, limbo figuratively refers to disturbance, anxiety, confusion, sadness, dissatisfaction, and anger. The Cambridge Dictionary also defines limbo as a situation, in which a person is located between two stages with an indefinite future or an uncontrollable uncertain situation. It is also used to refer to the world between this world and the hereafter, but neither the heaven nor the hell. Moreover, it is defined as anxiety, worry, inertia, frustration, anger, and fear.
Behavioral and emotional turmoil was one of the two main categories in this study. It refers to nurses' perceptions of the emotions and the behavioral reactions of terminally ill patients' family members in response to bad news about their patients' conditions. Similarly, a former study reported that witnessing patient's suffering worsens family members' emotional pain and loss experience. Our findings also showed that participating nurses had encountered families which were in shock, perplexity, and confusion after receiving bad news about their patients' conditions. In agreement with this finding, an earlier phenomenological study showed that families experienced bewilderment and shock in case of their patients' brain death. We also found that unexpected changes in patients' conditions, administration of new treatments, and recurrence of health-related problems make family members more disturbed, confused, sad, anxious, and impatient. In line with these findings, a study found that the family members of terminally ill patients experienced anxiety, sadness, uncertainty, guilt, anger, despair, and loneliness. Moreover, our participants had perceived fear and frustration among terminally ill patients' family members. Fear disturbs family members' lives and reduces their ability to cope with the reality of their patients' death.
Our findings also showed violent behaviors among family members after receiving bad news about their patients' conditions. A study showed that family members in most Middle East countries see hospitalization as a great misfortune, tragedy, and possible death. Bad news about patients' conditions causes anger for patients' family members and requires them to make unreasonable requests from health-care providers. Different from our findings, a study reported that family members may feel angry if they are not informed about their patients' conditions. Moreover, a study into the challenges experienced by nurses in dealing with brain-dead patients suggested that family members often blame nurses and roughly treat them when they are not well informed about their patients' conditions. This difference among the studies is attributable to the fact that our study did not aim to assess nurses' challenges in the process of care delivery; rather, it explored nurses' perceptions of the conditions of terminally ill patients' family members.
Another finding of the study was that terminally ill patients' family members sometimes blame themselves or nurses and also feel guilty due to their inappropriate behaviors toward their patients in the past and losing the golden opportunity to take care of their beloved ones. Similarly, a study indicated that continuous self-blame for what is happening to a dying patient is associated with the feeling of guilt. Moreover, our participants perceived financial problems among terminally ill patients' family members due to the high costs of hospitalization. Financial problems can give family members' feelings of helplessness and anxiety and thereby cause them emotional and social problems. Family members in Iran have close emotional ties with each other and hence the serious conditions of one of them can exert devastating effects on the others. We found that financial problems may eventually make family members' request for treatment discontinuation. This finding denotes that in case of a terminally ill patient, family members' worries about hospitalization costs overweigh the loss of their patient. In agreement with this finding, a study showed that financial burdens on family members make them prefer comforting care over life-extending care. According to the existing evidence, most insurance companies in Iran do not pay for end-of-life care; thus, terminally ill patients' family members may resort to their savings, apply for loans, or seek a second job to afford hospitalization costs.
The other findings of the present study were families' worries about their terminally ill patients' indefinite future due to the likelihood of unexpected events or unexpected treatment outcomes. Similarly, a former study reported that ambiguities about treatments and prognosis lead to uncertainties for family members. Simultaneously, postponing medical treatments to see the effects of current treatments may cause undue pain and suffering for family members.
One limitation of this study was related to sampling in only one city. Replication of this study in other cities can provide more conclusive evidence respecting nurses' perceptions of the conditions of terminally ill patients' family members. Another limitation was related to the lack of differentiation between nurses' perceptions of the conditions of family members of patients with acute and chronic health problems. Therefore, studies are needed to address this limitation. Moreover, we recommend studies to develop a valid and reliable instrument to measure the conditions of terminally ill patients' family members.
| Conclusion|| |
Emotional turmoil and perceived worries associated with the critical conditions of terminally ill patients place their family members in limbo. Family in limbo, the main theme of the study, reflects nurses' perceptions of emotional vulnerability in terminally ill patients' families. These findings contribute to the body of knowledge of nursing and can help develop effective family care plans for these families. Placement in limbo may expose family members to a pathologic grief. Thus, nurses need to develop and use preventive measures based on family members' conditions and needs in order to help them undergo a healthy grief.
This article is part of a PhD dissertation in nursing. The authors would like to thank all participating nurses for sharing their experiences.
Financial support and sponsorship
This study was financially supported by Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Hosseinrezaei H, Pilevarzadeh M, Amiri M, Rafiei H, Taghati S, Naderi M, et al.
Psychological symptoms in family members of brain death patients in intensive care unit in Kerman, Iran. Glob J Health Sci 2014;6:203-8.
Bainbridge D, Krueger P, Lohfeld L, Brazil K. Stress processes in caring for an end-of-life family member: Application of a theoretical model. Aging Ment Health 2009;13:537-45.
Veloso VI, Tripodoro VA. Caregivers burden in palliative care patients: A problem to tackle. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care 2016;10:330-5.
Rasouli-Ghahfarkhi SM, Molahosseini S. Stress and its related factors in families of patients with cancer. Chronic Dis J 2015;3:45-54.
Carter MA. Trust, power, and vulnerability: A discourse on helping in nursing. Nurs Clin North Am 2009;44:393-405.
Baliza MF, Bousso RS, Poles K, Santos MR, Silva L, Paganini MC, et al.
Factors influencing intensive care units nurses in end-of-life decisions. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2015;49:572-9.
Caswell G, Pollock K, Harwood R, Porock D. Communication between family carers and health professionals about end-of-life care for older people in the acute hospital setting: A qualitative study. BMC Palliat Care 2015;14:35.
Zaider T, Kissane D. The assessment and management of family distress during palliative care. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care 2009;3:67-71.
Ullrich A, Ascherfeld L, Marx G, Bokemeyer C, Bergelt C, Oechsle K, et al.
Quality of life, psychological burden, needs, and satisfaction during specialized inpatient palliative care in family caregivers of advanced cancer patients. BMC Palliat Care 2017;16:31.
Kirchhoff KT, Faas AI. Family support at end of life. AACN Adv Crit Care 2007;18:426-35.
Fernandes Mde F, Komessu JH. Nurses' challenges in view of the pain and suffering of families of terminal patients. Rev Esc Enferm USP 2013;47:250-7.
Parker Oliver D, Washington K, Smith J, Uraizee A, Demiris G. The prevalence and risks for depression and anxiety in hospice caregivers. J Palliat Med 2017;20:366-71.
Kobayakawa M, Ogawa A, Konno M, Kurata A, Hamano J, Morita T, et al.
Psychological and psychiatric symptoms of terminally ill patients with cancer and their family caregivers in the home-care setting: A nation-wide survey from the perspective of bereaved family members in Japan. J Psychosom Res 2017;103:127-32.
Probst DR, Gustin JL, Goodman LF, Lorenz A, Wells-Di Gregorio SM. ICU versus non-ICU hospital death: Family member complicated grief, posttraumatic stress, and depressive symptoms. J Palliat Med 2016;19:387-93.
Tahrekhani M, Abedi HA. The experiences of family members of non-organ donors on the crisis rising from patients' brain death. Nurs Midwifery Stud 2017;6:e40362.
Goudarzi F, Abedi HA, Zarea K, Ahmadinejad F. Caring experiences and challenges of families with patients in vegetative state. J Clin Nurs Midwifery 2015;4:65-79.
Hashemi M, Irajpour A, Taleghani F. Caregivers needing care: The unmet needs of the family caregivers of end-of-life cancer patients. Support Care Cancer 2018;26:759-66.
Ghaljeh M, Iranmanesh S, Nayeri ND, Tirgari B. Organizational challenges: A major obstacle at end of life care in Iran. Br J Med Med Res 2016;16:1-12.
Caswell G, Hardy B, Ewing G, Kennedy S, Seymour J. Supporting family carers in home-based end-of-life care: Using participatory action research to develop a training programme for support workers and volunteers. BMJ Support Palliat Care 2019;9:e4.
Elo S, Kyngäs H. The qualitative content analysis process. J Adv Nurs 2008;62:107-15.
Cleary M, Horsfall J, Hayter M. Data collection and sampling in qualitative research: Does size matter? J Adv Nurs 2014;70:473-5.
Graneheim UH, Lundman B. Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: Concepts, procedures and measures to achieve trustworthiness. Nurse Educ Today 2004;24:105-12.
Lincoln YS, Guba EG. Naturalistic inquiry. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications; 1985.
Dehkhoda A. Dictionary. Vol. 2. Tehran: University Publication; 2012.
Kurian G. Carthusians. The Encyclopedia of Christian Civilization. 1st
Ed, USA: Wiley-Blackwell; 2012.
Capps D, Carlin N. Living in limbo: Life in the midst of uncertainty. Wipf and Stock Publishers; 2010.
Rockliffe G. The importance of saying goodbye to a loved one in a pain-free environment. J Pain Palliat Care Pharmacother 2012;26:55-6.
Read T, Wuest J. Daughters caring for dying parents: A process of relinquishing. Qual Health Res 2007;17:932-44.
Nyatanga B. Inside the mind of a relative at the end of life. Br J Community Nurs 2012;17:333.
Bagherian S, Iranmanesh S, Dargahi H, Abbas Zadeh A. The attitude of nursing staff of institute cancer and Valie-Asr hospital toward caring for dying patients. J Qual Res Health Sci 2010;9:8-14.
Kirchhoff KT, Walker L, Hutton A, Spuhler V, Cole BV, Clemmer T, et al.
The vortex: Families' experiences with death in the intensive care unit. Am J Crit Care 2002;11:200-9.
Moghaddam HY, Manzari ZS, Heydari A, Mohammadi E, Khaleghi I. The nursing challenges of caring for brain-dead patients: A qualitative study. Nurs Midwifery Stud 2018;7:116-21. [Full text]
Iranmanesh S, Dargahi H, Abbaszadeh A. Attitudes of Iranian nurses toward caring for dying patients. Palliat Support Care 2008;6:363-9.
Gardiner C, Brereton L, Frey R, Wilkinson-Meyers L, Gott M. Exploring the financial impact of caring for family members receiving palliative and end-of-life care: A systematic review of the literature. Palliat Med 2014;28:375-90.
Amiresmaili MR, Imani E, Jahad Sarvestani A. Evaluation of terminal life cost for patients admitted in teaching hospitals affiliated with Kerman university of medical sciences in 2014. J Health Based Res 2015;1:133-43.
Spichiger E. Living with terminal illness: Patient and family experiences of hospital end-of-life care. Int J Palliat Nurs 2008;14:220-8.