|Year : 2021 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 27-33
Iranian Nurses' Experiences of their Roles in Care Provision to the Victims of Child Violence: A Qualitative Study
, Masoud Fallahi-Khoshknab1
, Mohammadali Hosseini1
, Fazlollah Ahmadi2
1 Department of Nursing, Faculty of Rehabilitation, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 Department of Nursing, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
|Date of Submission||25-Dec-2019|
|Date of Decision||28-Jan-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||02-May-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||14-Jan-2021|
Koodakyar St., Daneshjoo Ave., Evin, Tehran 1985713834
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: As the largest group of healthcare providers, nurses have many different responsibilities in care provision to child violence victims (CVVs). Yet, their roles in care provision to these victims are poorly known. Objectives: The aim of this study was to explore nurses' experiences of their roles in care provision to CVVs. Methods: This qualitative study was conducted in 2018–2019. Fourteen nurses were purposively recruited from two pediatric specialty hospitals in Tehran and Ardabil, Iran. In-depth semi-structured interviews were held for data collection. Data were analyzed through conventional content analysis. Results: Data analysis revealed that nurses' roles in care provision to CVVs included the four main categories of protective, diagnostic, reporting, and educational roles. Conclusions: Nurses play significant roles in care provision to CVVs through diagnosing violence, reporting it, protecting CVVs, and providing education to CVVs and their families. Nonetheless, they receive limited education, if any, in this area.
Keywords: Child abuse, Maltreatment, Nursing roles, Pediatric nursing, Qualitative study, Victims, Violence
|How to cite this article:|
Vosoghi N, Fallahi-Khoshknab M, Hosseini M, Ahmadi F. Iranian Nurses' Experiences of their Roles in Care Provision to the Victims of Child Violence: A Qualitative Study. Nurs Midwifery Stud 2021;10:27-33
|How to cite this URL:|
Vosoghi N, Fallahi-Khoshknab M, Hosseini M, Ahmadi F. Iranian Nurses' Experiences of their Roles in Care Provision to the Victims of Child Violence: A Qualitative Study. Nurs Midwifery Stud [serial online] 2021 [cited 2021 Mar 4];10:27-33. Available from: https://www.nmsjournal.com/text.asp?2021/10/1/27/306873
| Introduction|| |
Violence against children is a global health problem. It consists of all forms of violence against individuals under eighteen committed by parents, caregivers, peers, romantic partners, or strangers. The Department of Health and Human Services in the United States reported that in 2017, more than 57,000 children in this country suffered violence. This number is just the tip of the iceberg because only one twentieth of cases are reported. Iran has a population of more than 80 million, 31% of which are younger than 19 years of age. Violence against children is a crime in Iran. Despite studies in different areas of Iran into child violence, there is no overall estimation of its prevalence in the country. A systematic review in Iran showed that the prevalence rates of physical violence, emotional violence, and neglect were 9.7%–67.5%, 17.9%–91.1%, and 23.6%–80.18%, respectively. This study revealed a high prevalence of child abuse in Iran. It seems child abuse in Iran is in the critical condition.
Child violence has numerous detrimental personal and social consequences. The social cost of child violence in Japan was sixteen billion dollars in 2012, which is equivalent to the costs of Tokyo earthquake and Fukushima tsunami in 2011.
Providing care to child violence victims (CVVs) is among nurses' daily responsibilities. They have a key role in detecting all types of child violence. As the largest group of healthcare providers, nurses have numerous roles and responsibilities in providing care, improving care quality, enhancing health, and shaping the future of healthcare. Their professional roles include caring, educational, advocacy, research, managerial, consultative, and disease prevention roles.,, In the Health People 2020 initiative, the United States Department of Health and Human Services defined violence prevention as one of the most important roles of nurses.
Nurses' roles in preventing and reporting child violence are very complex due to the complexity of child violence phenomenon and vary in different countries. In some countries, they act as forensic nurses in dealing with CVVs. A qualitative study in Iran addressed barriers to child abuse reporting. Yet, nurses experiences of their roles in care provision to CVVs are poorly known and further studies are needed to provide detailed data in this area in the real world.
The aim of this study was to explore nurses' experiences of their roles in care provision to CVVs.
| Methods|| |
Design and participants
This qualitative study was done using conventional content analysis in 2018–2019.
Study setting was specialty pediatric wards in two pediatric specialty hospitals in Ardabil and Tehran, Iran. These two hospitals were Children's Medical Center affiliated to Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, and BooAli Children's Hospital affiliated to Ardabil University of Medical Sciences, Ardabil, Iran. Fourteen nurses were purposively recruited from emergency rooms, internal medicine wards, and pediatric intensive care units. Inclusion criteria were a work experience of more than 6 months in pediatric wards, experience of care provision to CVVs, and agreement for sharing personal experiences. Sampling was done with maximum variation concerning participants' gender, work experience, education level, marital status, and affiliated ward. [Table 1] shows Participants' characteristics.
Data were collected through in-depth semi-structured face-to-face interviews. Each interview was started using an open-ended question about care provision to CVVs, i.e. “What experiences do you have about care provision to CVVs?” Then, it was guided according to interviewee's response. With appointment, interviews were held in a room at participants' workplace. The length of interviews was 45–60 min. All interviews were held by the first author who had the experience of interaction with nurses in pediatric wards for 22 years as a nursing student, nurse, and clinical instructor. Interviews were recorded using a pocket voice recorder. In total, seventeen interviews were held with fourteen participants. Data collection was continued until reaching data saturation. After each interview, it was immediately transcribed and then, typed in Microsoft Office Word.
Immediately after the first interview, data analysis was started using conventional content analysis method proposed by Graneheim et al. Each interview transcript was reviewed several times. Then, meaning units were identified, abstracted, and coded. Codes were categorized into subcategories according to their similarities and then, subcategories were grouped to form main categories as the latent content of the data. [Table 2] shows an example of data analysis. The MAXQDA software (MAXQDA 10, Verbi company, Berlin, Germany) was employed to manage the data.
Trustworthiness was maintained using Lincoln and Guba's criteria, namely credibility, transferability, dependability, and confirmability. To maintain credibility, the first author had prolonged engagement with the data for more than 18 months. To ensure transferability, clear descriptions were provided about participants' characteristics such as age, gender, work experience, and educational level and all steps of the study were explained in detail. Dependability was ensured through peer checking by coauthors. The members of the study team were experienced qualitative researchers with extensive experience in research, nursing, and violence. During member checking, coauthors frequently reviewed the processes of data reduction, coding, and categorization. Moreover, data collection and analysis were performed simultaneously and all study documents (including interviews) were kept for auditing by others. Moreover, a piece of the data was simultaneously analyzed by two of the authors which produced similar results. To ensure confirmability, excerpts of the interview data and their corresponding codes were given to three participants. They approved the congruence between our findings and their own experiences.
This study was part of a PhD dissertation in nursing approved by the Ethics Committee of the University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran (code: IR.USWR.REC.1396.286). Study objectives were explained to all participants and they were ensured of the voluntary participation and confidential management of the study data. Informed consent for participation was obtained from all participants.
| Results|| |
Participants were fourteen nurses who had the experience of providing care to CVVs. Most participants were female and had bachelor's degree [Table 1].
None of the participants had already received educations about CVVs. All of them highlighted that their therapeutic role in relation to CVVs was the same as their therapeutic role in relation to other patients. Moreover, they claimed that they performed all therapeutic measures needed for CVVs, especially in the acute phase of managing violence-related injuries. The essence of nursing is care. Therapeutic role is seen everywhere in providing nursing care. As nurses' therapeutic role was clear and none of the participants clearly talked about it, we avoided addressing this role in detail in the present study.
In total, 78 codes were generated regarding nurses' experiences of their role in care provision to CVVs. These codes were categorized into nine subcategories and four main categories [Table 3]. The four main roles of nurses in care provision to CVVs were protective role, diagnostic role, reporting role, and educational role.
|Table 3: Subcategories and main categories of the study together with examples of their primary codes|
Click here to view
Participants considered CVVs as defenseless individuals and hence, attempted to protect them against possible injuries. They noted that violence is not a single event in the past; rather, it is a process started in the past which may continue in the future, resulting in further violent behaviors towards CVVs. Accordingly, they were vigilant about others' suspicious behaviors towards CVVs in order to protect them against other violent incidents. This main category consisted of three subcategories, namely monitoring people related to CVVs, attempting to meet the needs of CVVs and their families, and ensuring environmental safety.
Monitoring people related to child violence victims
Participants acted as guards for CVVs and attempted to protect them against potential risks.
Not only we are vigilant about suspicious visits in the morning shift, but also I tell nurses in the evening and the night shifts to be watchful about people who visit CVVs in their shifts in order to prevent them from harming CVVs (P. 3).
At the visitation time, I saw two men who separately introduced themselves as the child's father. To prevent potential risks, I checked all visitors and asked them to show their identity cards. This strategy revealed that none of those two men was the child's father (P. 2; explaining a case of suspicious child selling).
Attempting to meet the needs of child violence victims and their families
Participants attempted to meet the needs of CVVs and their families during their relationships with them. For instance, they bought gifts for CVVs in order to gain their trust.
We really support these children. For example, we attempt to make them happy by giving them a doll, a toy car, or a small thing. Children become happy with small things. By this technique, we try to establish close relationship with them and make them hopeful. Some time they have not clothes and diapers due to poor economic conditions, we provide for them (P. 7).
Participants not only personally protected CVVs, but also attempted to introduce them to support groups and organizations despite having no clear guideline for such introduction. Public health nurses have no distinct position in the healthcare system of Iran and hence, there are problems in care provision to CVVs after they are discharged from hospital. Therefore, our participants attempted to meet the psychological and financial needs of CVVs and their families even after hospital discharge.
We support them. Sometimes, we refer them to NGOs that provide them with psychological and financial support (P. 8).
Ensuring environmental safety
Nurses have improved the environment safety for child protection. Some time they provided outdoor security guard for child protection.
Sometimes, I ask a security staff to stay in front of the ward entrance and close the door and the windows because somebody may kidnap the child (P. 10).
Nurses have an important role in diagnosing violence against CVVs. This category consisted of two subcategories. [Table 2] shows details.
Suspicion about violence due to inconsistent statements of child violence victims' companions
The companions of the child did not say anything to us. Instead of her parents, a boy from relatives had taken the child to hospital. Inconsistent statements made us get suspicious that there was a problem. The 3-year-old girl behaved like adults and used make-up (P. 7).
The stepfather of the child said that the child slipped in the bathroom and experienced head trauma. However, some other parts of the child's body were also bruised and his mother said that he had a fall in the yard. Thereby, I found that they were not telling the truth (P. 1).
Suspicion about violence based on history and examination data
Participants noted that they suspected violence against children based on the data they obtained during history taking and clinical examination. Moreover, they noticed evidence of violence during changing children's position. Inconsistencies between the data obtained through history taking from children and the data obtained during interviewing their parents also made them suspect violence.
We had a 12-year-old girl with rectal bleeding. History data were not consistent with clinical symptoms and the data provided by family members. Further examination revealed a rape (P. 11).
Nurses' role in violence reporting had two subcategories, namely reporting child abuse to other healthcare providers and reporting child abuse to child protection staff.
Reporting violence to other healthcare providers
Participants noted that they were responsible for reporting any evidence of child violence to their colleagues and superiors, including head nurse, nursing manager, physicians, social workers, and forensic doctor resident in their hospitals.
When providing care to a hospitalized boy whose mother had hurt him, I informed our head nurse. She asked me to inform the supervisor and the social worker of the hospital and I did it (P. 2).
Reporting child abuse to child protection staff
Besides intra-organizational reporting of violence, participants highlighted that they reported cases of child violence to authorities out of their organizations, including public prosecutors, judicial authorities, and police. Moreover, some parents were unaware of violence against their children and hence, participants informed them.
Evidence of assault on all parts of the child's body, from the face to the extremities, made us suspicious of violence. Therefore, we informed the social workers of our center as well as the child's mother. Social workers and the child's mother attended our ward. There, it was proved that the child's stepfather had hurt him. We reported the case to judicial authorities (P. 1).
A 13-year-old child with rectal bleeding was brought to the emergency unit. While examining her, we noticed she was raped. We informed her parents; but the poor girl died due to severe bleeding (P. 13).
While providing care to CVVs, nurses also play educational roles. They provide education to CVVs and their parents in order to reduce their stress.
Teaching children to reduce their stress
Nurses make effort to practically educate the children the ways of reducing tension and anxiety.
The PICU nurse with 12 years of clinical experience talked about one of her experiences and said: “A kid who was abused and admitted to the ward I brought him a painting and storybook book that we have in the ward and asked him to come and play whenever he wanted” (P. 4).
Providing education to child violence victims' parents to reduce child violence victims' stress
Participants also trained CVVs' parents to use techniques for reducing CVVs' stress. These techniques included reading stories, painting, and spending time with children at playroom. A participant described her experience of providing education to the parents of a child who had been raped by the child's companion in the nursery way:
I told them to take their child to the nursery themselves and not to trust anyone. I also taught them some preventive techniques. They were very upset and I asked them not to cry at their child's beside in order to ease the child's stress (P. 1).
| Discussion|| |
Findings revealed that beside therapeutic role, nurses played many different roles in providing care to CVVs, namely protective role, diagnostic role, educational role, and reporting role.
Protective role was the most important role of nurses in care provision to CVVs. Providing protective and safeguarding care to CVVs is one of the daily responsibilities of nurses. Nursing interventions to protect children against abuse vary from prevention, diagnosis, and postabuse interventions. Despite the necessity of playing active role by healthcare providers in child protection against violence, a population-based study in Germany showed that 19% of participants had experienced at least one type of violence committed by nurses. This is against the principles of ethical nursing practice which require nurses to protect children and take care of them.
After getting suspicious about violence, our participants attempted to assess suspicious cases of child violence and help physicians in diagnosis. Nurses have a significant role in diagnosing child violence. Early diagnosis of violence is important for early beginning of comprehensive care.
In 2002, the parliament of Iran enacted the child protection law with nine components. According to the first component, child abuse is considered a general crime without any need for plaintiff's complaint. The sixth component also requires all individuals, institutes, and centers that are in charge of care provision to children to report any case of child abuse for further prosecution. Avoidance from such reporting is considered a crime.
Care provision to CVVs is a multidisciplinary task and hence, nurses should report cases of child violence to the members and authorities of healthcare team. The findings of the present study showed that nurses played significant role in reporting child violence cases to other healthcare providers and relevant authorities. Similarly, a former study in Iran reported that nurses actively engaged in reporting child violence to relevant authorities. A study in Korea also introduced violence reporting as one of the main responsibilities of nurses and recommended that nurses should be provided with educations about appropriate violence reporting and should be supported by authorities to appropriately and confidently report cases of violence.
Our participants also noted that they attempted to provide education to CVVs and their families in order to reduce their stress and prevent further injuries to them. Two earlier studies showed that pediatric nurse practitioners had the necessary knowledge and skills for providing care to CVVs., Moreover, education can improve nurses' violence-related knowledge. However, none of our participants were nurse practitioner and had received any violence-related education. Similarly, a study in Pakistan and a study in Africa reported that healthcare providers received no meaningful education regarding child violence and hence, had limited violence-related knowledge. Therefore, coherent educational programs are needed to improve nurses' knowledge about child violence. The Committee of School Nurses also highlighted that nurses should be responsive to and responsible for children, be aware of the strategies for reporting child violence, protect children against potential risks, be provided with educations about the signs and symptoms of child violence, act as a bridge between families and society, and collaborate with organizations to prevent and reduce child violence and its complications.
In line with our findings, a study showed that psychiatric nurses have numerous roles in care provision to CVVs including reporting suspected cases of child violence, assessing and treating CVVs, providing violence-related education to children, and acting as a legal expert and a member of a multidisciplinary team in order to protect children against violence. Another study also noted the necessity of working in a multidisciplinary team for effective child violence prevention and management.
Provision of training programs to prevent and manage violence can lead to minimizing the consequences.
Because of limited resources, this study was conducted only in two hospitals. Moreover, most nurses in pediatric wards were female and hence, we could include only two male nurses in the study. Future studies can show whether male nurses have different experiences.
| Conclusions|| |
Nurses play numerous roles in care provision to CVVs. These roles include protecting CVVs against potential risks, diagnosing cases of child violence, providing CVVs and their families with education in order to reduce their stress, and reporting suspected cases of child violence to colleagues and authorities. However, they receive limited education, if any, about violence and its diagnosis, reporting, prevention, and management. Therefore, university-based and in-service educational programs are needed for improving their violence-related knowledge and their ability to diagnose, report, prevent, and manage violence.
Researchers express their sincere gratitude to all participants in the study. Without their cooperation, this study would not have been possible.
Financial support and sponsorship
This study was supported by the University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Herendeen PA, Blevins R, Anson E, Smith J. Barriers to and consequences of mandated reporting of child abuse by nurse practitioners. J Pediatr Health Care 2014;28:e1-7.
Hornor G, Zeno R. Child sexual abuse perpetrators: What forensic nurses need to know. J Forensic Nurs 2018;14:206-13.
Mohammadi MR, Zarafshan H, Khaleghi A. Child abuse in Iran: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Iran J Psychiatry 2014;9:118-24.
Albuquerque LM, Carvalho CM, Apostólico MR, Sakata KN, Cubas MR, Egry EY. Nursing terminology defines domestic violence against children and adolescents. Rev Bras Enferm 2015;68:393-400, 452-9.
Wada I, Igarashi A. The social costs of child abuse in Japan. Child Youth Serv Rev 2014;46:72-7.
Ben Natan M, Faour C, Naamhah S, Grinberg K, Klein-Kremer A. Factors affecting medical and nursing staff reporting of child abuse. Int Nurs Rev 2012;59:331-7.
Salmond SW, Echevarria M. Healthcare transformation and changing roles for nursing. Orthop Nurs 2017;36:12-25.
Shamian J. The role of nursing in health care. Rev Bras Enferm 2014;67:867-8.
Potter PA, Perry AG, Stockert P, Hall A. Fundamentals of Nursing-E-Book. USA: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2016.
Simon TR, Hurvitz K. Healthy people 2020 objectives for violence prevention and the role of nursing. Online J Issues Nurs 2014;19:1.
Jordan KS, Steelman SH. Child maltreatment: Interventions to improve recognition and reporting. J Forensic Nurs 2015;11:107-13.
Lines LE, Hutton AE, Grant J. Integrative review: Nurses' roles and experiences in keeping children safe. J Adv Nurs 2017;73:302-22.
Borimnejad L, Fomani KF. Child abuse reporting barriers: Iranian nurses' experiences. Iran Red Crescent Med J 2015;17:e22296.
Graneheim UH, Lindgren BM, Lundman B. Methodological challenges in qualitative content analysis: A discussion paper. Nurse Educ Today 2017;56:29-34.
Tuckett AG. Part II. Rigour in qualitative research: Complexities and solutions. Nurse Res 2005;13:29-42.
Tweedlie J, Vincent S. Adult student nurses' experiences of encountering perceived child abuse or neglect during their community placement: Implications for nurse education. Nurse Educ Today 2019;73:60-4.
Lines L, Grant J, Hutton A. How do nurses keep children safe from abuse and neglect, and does it make a difference? A scoping review. J Pediatr Nurs 2018;43:e75-84.
Clemens V, Hoffmann U, König E, Sachser C, Brähler E, Fegert JM. Child maltreatment by nursing staff and caregivers in German institutions: A population-representative analysis. Child Abuse Neglect 2019;95:104046.
Caneira L, Myrick KM. Diagnosing child abuse: The role of the nurse practitioner. J Nurs Pract 2015;11:640-6.
Lee HM, Kim JS. Predictors of intention of reporting child abuse among emergency nurses. J Pediat Nurs 2018;38:E47-52.
Hornor G. Child neglect: Assessment and intervention. J Pediat Health Care 2014;28:186-92.
Hornor G, Herendeen P. Advanced practice nursing in child maltreatment: Practice characteristics. J Pediat Health Care 2014;28:438-43.
Dianati M, Azizi-Fini I, Oghalaee Z, Gilasi H, Savari F. The impacts of nursing staff education on perceived abuse among hospitalized elderly people: A field trial. Nurs Midwifery Stud 2019;8:149-54. [Full text]
Maul KM, Naeem R, Khan UR, Mian AI, Yousafzai AK, Brown N. Child abuse in Pakistan: A qualitative study of knowledge, attitudes and practice amongst health professionals. Child Abuse Neglect 2019;88:51-7.
Abdool N, Brysiewicz P. A description of the forensic nursing role in emergency departments in Durban, South Africa. J Emerg Nurs 2009;35:16-21.
Linnarsson JR, Benzein E, Årestedt K, Erlingsson C. Preparedness to care for victims of violence and their families in emergency departments. Emerg Med J 2013;30:198-201.
Ellington E. Psychiatric nursing's role in child abuse: Prevention, recognition, and treatment. J Psychosoc Nurs Ment Health Serv 2017;55:16-20.
Fallahi-Khoshknab M, Oskouie F, Najafi F, Ghazanfari N, Tamizi Z, Afshani S. Physical violence against health care workers: A nationwide study from Iran. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res 2016;21:232-8.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]